📋 Case Study

Iron Ore Mine Waste Rock Long-Term Stability at Brockman 4 (Pilbara)

Massive hematite-goethite waste rock (low sulfide but high Mn/Al) showing delayed acidity and Al leaching post-construction

🏗️ Project Overview

Brockman 4 mine expansion (Rio Tinto, WA), 2018–2023

🎯 Challenge

Massive hematite-goethite waste rock (low sulfide but high Mn/Al) showing delayed acidity and Al leaching post-construction

🔧 Design Approach

Multi-phase reactive transport modeling (CrunchFlow) incorporating Mn redox cycling and Al-hydroxide precipitation kinetics; validated against 5-year field lysimeter data

📐 Design Diagram

Field Lysimeters(5-yr data)CrunchFlow Model(Mn redox + Al kinetics)Reactive TransportDelayed Acidity & Al LeachingAl solubility limit: 0.18 mg/L[Al³⁺] = Ksp/[OH⁻]³MnO₂ reduction rate:k·[MnO₂]·[Fe²⁺] = 1.2×10⁻⁴ s⁻¹Hematite-Goethite Waste RockLow sulfide, high Mn/AlBrockman 4Pilbara, WA

AI-generated project design illustration

📐 Key Calculations

Al Solubility Limit

[Al³⁺] = Ksp / [OH⁻]³
Result: 0.18 mg/L
Explained observed Al breakthrough at pH 4.7–5.1

MnO₂ Reduction Rate

k·[MnO₂]·[Fe²⁺]
Result: 1.2×10⁻⁴ s⁻¹
Controlled acid generation lag phase

📊 Results

Model predicted Al peak at year 6.2 ± 0.4 — measured at year 6.5; pH rebounded to 6.1 by year 8; no regulatory exceedances

💡 Lessons Learned

  • Goethite reactivity dominates long-term behavior more than hematite
  • Field lysimeters captured heterogeneity missed in lab columns
  • CrunchFlow’s kinetic mineral database required custom Mn-oxide parameters
  • Al leaching preceded acidity — early warning indicator
  • Rainfall intensity distribution (not just total) governed solute transport timing
  • Calibration required 3 independent tracer datasets (Cl⁻, SO₄²⁻, Al)

Key Takeaways

  • 1Goethite reactivity dominates long-term behavior more than hematite
  • 2Field lysimeters captured heterogeneity missed in lab columns
  • 3CrunchFlow’s kinetic mineral database required custom Mn-oxide parameters
  • 4Al leaching preceded acidity — early warning indicator
  • 5Rainfall intensity distribution (not just total) governed solute transport timing
  • 6Calibration required 3 independent tracer datasets (Cl⁻, SO₄²⁻, Al)